"Bad Therapy," written by investigative journalist Abigail Shrier, explores the alarming condition of mental health among Generation Z. Shrier argues that mental health professionals are the real problem, not children.

The Author

Shrier is known for her work on gender and societal issues. She graduated with the highest honors from Columbia University and received a Kellett Fellowship. Her academic journey continued at Oxford University and Yale Law School. After completing her studies, Shrier worked as the Honorable Judith W. Rogers' law clerk on the U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, D.C. She transitioned to a literary career and has written for The Wall Street Journal and other publications.

Shrier gained global recognition for her acclaimed book, "Irreversible Damage," which was honored as a "Best Book" by both the Economist and the Times and translated into 10 languages.

Uncovering Drawbacks and Pitfalls in Child Mental Health Care

Shrier examines how the mental health industry has impacted children's education, treatment, discipline, and communication strategies, drawing from extensive interviews with various stakeholders, including psychologists, parents, teachers, and young individuals.

The book reveals unsettling findings, such as the potential drawbacks of talk therapy, the limitations of social-emotional learning (SEL), and the pitfalls of certain parenting approaches. Shrier argues that while mental health care is crucial for children with severe needs, for the typical child, some therapeutic methods may have serious side effects and limited benefits.

Shrier's overarching argument in "Bad Therapy" asserts that the distress experienced by Generation Z is largely iatrogenic, meaning it is caused by the treatment meant to alleviate it - specifically, what she deems as 'bad therapy.' Shrier explores how therapeutic thinking has significantly influenced parents' approaches to socializing their children, replacing traditional displays of authority with attempts at reasoning, cajoling, begging, and blackmailing. 

READ ALSO: Jenny Slate Shares Journey Into Motherhood With Upcoming Book 'Lifeform'

When faced with challenges in parenting, individuals often seek self-proclaimed experts who provide newly coined labels like 'sensory processing issues,' 'oppositional defiant disorder,' or 'social anxiety disorder.' Shrier highlights the prevalence of mental health diagnoses, with 42 percent of the rising generation having received one, as indicative of the impact of what she considers detrimental therapeutic interventions.

Perspectives on Abigail Shrier's Critique

A review article in City Journal acknowledged that Shrier's book, "Bad Therapy," may face criticism for its speculative nature, especially from academics, entrenched parents, and educators who might not be receptive to Shrier's thesis. Shrier focuses on 'the worriers; the fearful; the lonely, lost, and sad,' differentiating them from the genuinely mentally ill.

The reviewer raised the possibility that some children may experience deep anxiety, loneliness, and sadness for reasons unrelated to iatrogenic factors. Despite potential criticism, the reviewer commended Shrier for her courage and determination, particularly in the aftermath of her previous book, "Irreversible Damage." The reviewer anticipated that Shrier's new work might provoke reactions from the mental-health establishment and educators.

An article in the Financial Times described Shier's book as a fast-paced and uncompromising critique of mental health professionals and parenting experts, likely to unsettle many therapists. Shrier addresses common issues such as over-medicalization and smartphone use while introducing new analyses. She unveils the widespread use of school surveys that ask young children leading questions about their feelings, highlighting instances in various states.

Shrier expresses deep sympathy for parents and directs her strongest criticism towards parenting 'experts' who, in her opinion, encourage an unhealthy fixation on problems and sometimes advocate for false diagnoses. While she is critical of therapy, Shrier's unequivocal support for parents and teenagers makes the book thought-provoking and uncomfortable but ultimately supportive of parental instincts.

According to a Slate article, "Bad Therapy" contends that normal childhood distress is being pathologized, limiting children's opportunities for independence and risk-taking. Shrier argues that therapy is not the solution and takes issue with generalizing emotional literacy teachings in schools, specifically SEL curricula.

While acknowledging the rise in diagnosis is concerning, some critics argued that Shrier oversimplifies the issue, suggesting that therapy is universally problematic and questioning the benefits of SEL. The reviewer criticized Shrier's broad generalizations about therapy and SEL for lacking nuance and overlooking potential positive impacts in certain contexts.

Despite varied perspectives on her claims, "Bad Therapy" prompts essential discussions on the impact of therapeutic interventions on children's well-being and the need for nuanced approaches in addressing the mental health crisis among the youth.

RELATED ARTICLE: Dr. Mariel Buqué's New Book Explores the Long-Term Impact of Trauma and Strategies for Healing